By Elira Venn
3 November 2026
A reflection on the difference between being believed and becoming certain.
An imagined scene.
By the time I reach my friend's kitchen, the meeting has acquired a villain.
I did not have one when I left the community hall. I had a folded sheet of paper, a headache, and an uncertain sense that something had gone wrong. We were planning a small neighborhood exhibition. I had suggested leaving one wall for work made by people who had never exhibited before. Daniel had looked at the floor plan and said, “We need to be realistic about the space.”
I stopped explaining. Someone asked about lighting. The meeting continued.
On the walk over, I could still hear several possible meanings in his sentence. Perhaps he thought the idea was impractical. Perhaps he wanted measurements. Perhaps he was dismissing me. I disliked the third possibility enough to keep returning to it.
Now my friend puts two cups on the table and asks how it went.
“You know Daniel,” I say. “He shut the whole thing down.”
She makes a small sound of recognition. She has had a difficult conversation with him herself. I feel the relief of not having to explain why his manner might bother me.
“He doesn't like anyone changing his plans,” she says.
And suddenly I have a much smoother story to tell.
The detail that disappears
I describe the meeting again. This time I imitate his voice. My friend laughs, then looks annoyed on my behalf. I tell her that nobody supported me.
There is a pause while she fetches the milk. In it, I remember the woman beside the door asking how many pictures I had in mind. I had answered, “I don't know yet,” and looked down at my notes.
That detail has not appeared in either telling.
Including it would not prove that Daniel was welcoming. It would, however, make “nobody supported me” less secure. Someone had asked a question that might have been a beginning. I had been too embarrassed to find out.
My friend returns. I want to continue with the version we have already started building. It has rhythm. It gives both of us a clear place to stand. Adding the question about the pictures would require slowing down and admitting that I do not entirely know what happened.
“She did ask how many pieces,” I say eventually. “The woman near the door.”
My friend sits down.
“Did you have a number?”
“No.”
The room becomes quieter without becoming unfriendly.
What the telling can do
Research on audience tuning offers a limited but useful connection to this invented scene. In three experiments, Echterhoff, Higgins and Groll examined how adapting a message to an audience could be associated with a later bias in the communicator's memory of a person. The pattern depended on features of the social situation, including trust in the audience's judgment. [1]
A later series of four experiments found greater memory bias when message tuning served the creation of a shared reality than when it served other goals, such as entertainment or obtaining incentives. [2]
These were controlled experimental tasks, not studies of my fictional kitchen or a method for deciding whose account of a real disagreement is correct. They do not show that every sympathetic listener distorts memory. They do suggest a reason to pay attention to what happens when a version of events becomes something we hold together.
In this scene, the question is not whether my friend should have been less kind. I came to her because I wanted company with a disappointment. The difficulty begins when the comfort of agreement also feels like confirmation of another person's motive.
She was not at the meeting. Her recognition can tell me that my account makes sense to her. It cannot, on its own, tell either of us what Daniel intended.
Leaving room inside an explanation
For readers interested in NEDS, this is a useful place to keep an interpretation provisional. The founder's conceptual appraisal explicitly identifies interpretive suggestion and confirmation bias as risks. [3, section 14] The experimental papers above do not validate NEDS, but their questions offer a relevant caution for conversations that use its language.
Suppose I describe a recurring expectation of being dismissed. That might organize several questions: what I anticipated before speaking, what I noticed in the room, why I stopped explaining, and what I wanted from the conversation afterward. It would remain a proposed reading, not an established mechanism.
My friend could make that reading feel very persuasive by recognizing every detail I offered. We would still need to ask what we had left out. A shared explanation can be specific and emotionally convincing while depending on a narrow selection of observations.
There is also a danger in making uncertainty do too much work. I do not need to deny that the exchange hurt. Nor must every difficult experience be reopened until I can no longer trust my own description. The smaller distinction is between the words I remember, my response to them, and the intention I have assigned to the speaker.
Those three things can sit beside each other without becoming equally certain.
A sentence I can still stand behind
“I felt dismissed,” I tell my friend.
“I can understand that,” she says.
I do not feel less supported. If anything, I feel less obliged to keep improving the case against Daniel. I can describe the moment I stopped speaking without having to establish that he wanted me silent.
Before leaving, I unfold the floor plan. There may be room for six small pictures. There may not. I decide to ask whether that number could work, and to say that I had left the meeting unsure whether the idea was still being considered.
This will not settle his character. He might answer impatiently. The proposal might be rejected. The scene offers no promise that careful wording will repair a relationship, and no demonstration of a therapeutic change.
It leaves me with a more usable account of an ordinary disappointment. There were words I heard, possibilities I supplied, and a conversation in which one possibility became easier to believe.
My friend washes the cups while I put the paper back in my bag. We have not reached a verdict. She still walks me to the door.
Sources and further reading
[1] Echterhoff, G., Higgins, E. T., & Groll, S. (2005). Audience-tuning effects on memory: The role of shared reality. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 89(3), 257–276. Primary research record and abstract.
[2] Echterhoff, G., Higgins, E. T., Kopietz, R., & Groll, S. (2008). How communication goals determine when audience tuning biases memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 137(1), 3–21. Primary research record and abstract.
[3] Kržić, M. (2026). From Structural Limits to a Testable Response: NEDS as a candidate relational and process-based framework for psychotherapeutic change. Version 1.0, section 14. The founder's conceptual appraisal and research program, not independent validation. Zenodo DOI.
Editorial note
Elira Venn is a virtual editorial persona affiliated with NEDS Institute. This AI-generated essay uses an imagined first-person scene. It is not personal testimony, an independent endorsement, a clinical assessment, or evidence of NEDS's effectiveness.
Also available on the NEDS Wiki.